Vahid on Epistemic Goals

The November edition of Philosophical Studies there appears this article of likely interest to our readers by Hamid Vahid.

"Aiming at Truth: Doxastic vs. Epistemic Goals"

Abstract Belief is generally thought to be the primary cognitive state representing the world as being a certain way, regulating our behavior and guiding us around the world. It is thus regarded as being constitutively linked with the truth of its content. This feature of belief has been famously captured in the thesis that believing is a purposive state aiming at truth. It has however proved to be notoriously difficult to explain what the thesis really involves. In this paper, I begin by critically examining a number of recent attempts to unpack the metaphor. I shall then proceed to highlight an error that seems to cripple most of these attempts. This involves the confusion between, what I call, doxastic and epistemic goals. Finally, having offered my own positive account of the aim-of-belief thesis, I shall underline its deflationary nature by distinguishing between aiming at truth and hitting that target (truth). I end by comparing the account with certain prominent inflationary theories of the nature of belief.

References

Alston, W. (1988): ‘The Deontological Conception of Epistemic Justification’, reprinted in Epistemic Justification , Cornell University Press, 1989.

BonJour, L. (1985): The Structure of Empirical Knowledge, Harvard University Press.

Bratman, M. (1999): ‘Practical Reasoning and Acceptance in a Context’, in Faces of Intention, Cambridge University Press.

Chisholm, R. (1987): Theory of Knowledge, 2nd edn., Prentice-Hall.

Cohen, J. (1992): An Essay on Belief and Acceptance, Oxford.

David, M. (2001): ‘Truth as the Epistemic Goal’ in M. Steup (ed.), Knowledge, Truth and Duty, Oxford University Press.

Davidson, D. (1984): ‘Radical Interpretation.’, in Truth and Interpretation, Oxford.

Davidson, D. (1986): ‘A Coherence Theory of Truth and Knowledge’, in E. LePore, (ed.), Truth and Interpretation, Basil Blackwell.

Foley, R. (1987): The Theory of Epistemic Rationality, Harvard University Press. Humberstone, L. (1992) "‘Direction of Fit’" Mind 101: 59-83

Kelly, T. (2003) "‘Epistemic Rationality as Instrumental Rationality: A Critique’" Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. LXVI 3: 612-640

Owens, D. (2003) "‘Does Belief Have an Aim?’" Philosophical Studies 115: 283-305

Velleman, D. (2000a): ‘On the Aim of Belief’, in The Possibility of Practical Reason, Oxford University Press.

Velleman, D. (2000b): ‘The Possibility of Practical Reason’, in The Possibility of Practical Reason, Oxford University Press.

Unwin, N. (2003) "‘What Does it Mean to Aim at Truth’" American Philosophical Quaterly 40: 91-104

Wedgwood, R. (2002) "‘The Aim of Belief’" Philosophical Perspectives 16: 267-297

Williams, B. (1973): ‘Deciding to Believe’ in Problems of the Self, Cambridge University Press.